Most pool equipment gives you warning before it dies. The warning is usually a noise, a tripped breaker, or a number on a display that has drifted.
Below is what we get called out for, what each one turns out to be, and whether a repair is worth paying for.
Why does my pool pump trip the breaker?
This is our most common call. Three things cause almost all of them.
The motor bearings have gone. You will have heard it coming for a few weeks: a grinding or screeching noise, worst at start up. Bearings can be replaced, though on a motor of eight or ten years you are rebuilding the cheapest part of an old machine.
Water has got into the motor. A failed shaft seal lets water past into the back of the motor. That one is obvious once the housing is open, and it usually ends the motor.
The pump is fine. A breaker weakens with age, and a GFCI can be doing its job because something upstream is wet. A timer can also have a wiring fault.
Rule out that third group before anyone quotes you a motor. It is the cheapest of the three by a wide margin.
Worth repairing? A motor under about five years old with good bearings, yes. An older single speed motor, usually no, for the reason in the next section.
Should I replace a single speed pump with a variable speed one?
Usually yes, and the reason is the electricity bill more than the pump.
A single speed pump works flat out whenever it is on. A variable speed pump turns slower for longer.
Power draw falls away much faster than speed does. So half speed for twice as long uses far less electricity than full speed for half the time.
On a pool that works twelve months a year, which is every pool here, that gap adds up.
Two things to know before you get quoted.
- Florida requires many replacement pool pumps above a certain size to be variable speed. On plenty of pools this is no longer a choice.
- The pump has to suit the plumbing it goes onto. A pump too big for the pipe is loud, wasteful and hard on the system.
Why does my pool heater start and then shut off?
A heater that lights and quits after a minute is usually protecting itself. Something upstream is wrong and it will not fire into a fault.
Here are the causes, cheapest first.
- Not enough water moving through it. A dirty filter, a clogged pump basket, or a half closed valve.
- A dirty or corroded flame sensor on a gas heater. This one cleans up.
- A failing high limit switch. That is a part, not a heater.
- A cracked heat exchanger. This is the expensive one.
Worth repairing? The first three, easily. A cracked heat exchanger on a heater over about ten years old, rarely.
Check the filter before you call anybody. A large share of heater callouts end there.
Why is my salt cell reading low or asking me to check it?
Salt cells are consumable. They have a working life, they wear out, and a worn cell is a replacement.
Before you buy one, three other things look identical on the display.
- Scale on the plates. Cells build up calcium and need cleaning. A scaled cell reads low while being nowhere near worn out.
- Salt level. Low salt reads as a cell fault on most systems.
- Water temperature. Cells produce less in cold water, so a low reading in January can be normal.
Worth repairing? Cells cannot be repaired, though most of them clean up, at a fraction of the cost of a new one.
What fails early on the coast?
Everything above happens anywhere. These go faster here.
Pools in Indialantic, Satellite Beach, Melbourne Beach, Cocoa Beach and Cape Canaveral live in salt air, and salt air eats metal. Heater cabinets, control panel housings, light rings, rails and anchors all corrode faster within a few miles of the water.
That is the address, never a maintenance failure. On the beach side, expect the metal to age before the mechanicals do. Rinse the equipment pad more often than the manual suggests.
What to do about it
Three habits save most of the money on this list.
- Do not ignore a noise. A motor caught early is a repair, and the same motor caught late is a motor.
- Clean the filter before you call about the heater.
- Ask what failed and why. If nobody can tell you what killed the part, the same thing kills the next one.
When it is time for somebody to look at it, our pool equipment repair page covers what we work on and how we quote it. We will also tell you when a unit is not worth putting money into. That call is worth getting from somebody who is not selling you the replacement the same day.
